DVD The Secret Lives of Dentists
The passion of oral surgeons is the unlikely subject of The Secret Lives of Dentists, Alan Rudolph's keenly observed comedy-drama. Campbell Scott and Hope Davis, dentists both, have three kids and a pleasant life. Pleasant, but not exciting. When Scott realizes his wife is having an affair on the side, he's torn between caution and an outrageous inner voice urging drastic action. That voice is personified by Denis Leary, who pops up with unwelcome advice, like a nattering ghost; needless to say, the role is a perfect fit for Leary's hostile persona. The blend of everyday realities--especially a hilariously miserable five-day siege with stomach flu--and Leary's surreal presence makes for a typically offbeat Rudolph offering. The smart script, after a Jane Smiley story, is by Craig Lucas. Indie stalwarts Scott and Davis both do subtle work--they're as careful and scrupulous as the dentists they portray. --Robert Horton |
| Previous Page |
 |
Review(s): DVD The Secret Lives of Dentists |  |
| Walter Mitty-Like Suburban Dentist Has the Blues |
This is one of the more satisfying films I've seen this year. Its of the serious comedy genre. Dentists will be interested but its not particularly about dentists. Its about the difficulty of maintaining intimacy in modern marriage and what that lack can lead to. Its a re make of the Thurber/Danny Kaye Secret Life of Walter Mitty.Campbell Scott and wife Hope Davis work as partner dentists in suburban New York. The couple have been married ten years, they have three daughters. Scott is more sympatico and caring of the girls than his wife, and they both know it. A cynical trumpet player patient, Dennis Leary, criticizes Scott's dental work and browbeats him publicly into re-fixing his free, though Leary wrecked the dental work by not following advice. The Spirit of Leary hangs about the House giving Scott advice on how to deal with his problems. The children are a constant battle. The absences of the wife spur suspicion and fearful fantasy. . Scott begins to fantasize that his wife is secretly cuckolding him, and he imagines fantasies of what a a new romantic life of his own would be like. The Couple are chained to their Practice, but even more chained to the troublesome and irksome children. There is a five day bout with the flu that puts both dentists to bed but still waiting on their vomiting children hand and foot, Scott doing most of the work. The film raises questions about the tacit but never discussed secrets, shared but never spoken of, between modern marrieds. Scott, son of actor George C. Scott, is in the best role of his life. This is also certainly the best film Robert Altman disciple Alan Rudolph has ever made. Dennis Leary is pretty good as the low-life musician with a pair of Elvis-on-tour aviators, a bad brown leather jacket, bad hair and other sartorial woes. He is a cross between the Bogey character in Play it Again Sam and the Sheldon Leonard character, Grogan, who used to show up in the foodstore to criticize and torment poor Jack Benny. The film is a little like American Beauty but more realistic and less the joke you can't take seriously. Its good. I had hoped for a better ending. In fact I could have written one I like better but this one will do. Despite the ending, and a slight lengthiness, I would recommend it highly. ...
|  |
| Some-what depressing, but a good look at marriage. |
I love Indie movies, "Why?" you may ask? Because they usually much better at depicting real humans then Hollywood films are. And okay, some indie films are just as bad as Hollywood films, that's a given, you *always* have to sift through the crap to find the good stuff. But as with anything, when you find the good stuff, the search was worth it.! So, anyways, I will say that to me, this movie was fairly depressing. It moved fairly slow, but it fit the film, and it went by pretty fast. I felt the relationship between Dave and Dana was handled really well. And the performances by Campbell Scott and Hope Davis were wonderful. All the acting in the film was great, I especially like Denis Leary in this movie, and generally I dislike him(A LOT), but he's PERFECT for the role he plays here.! I just like watching what Dave is going through, it just seems what I'd be thinking if my husband were cheating on me. Or some-what like thoughts I've had about people hating me. Its fun watching him play-out scenarios in his mind as well. I mean generally the main problem with marriages and many relationships is lack of communication. That's especially true in this film, they've gotten so wrapped up in they're day-to-day lives they don't have very much real communication. When one of them tries to communicate the other isn't in the mood to listen. And of course their's the whole affair thing with his wife, so she is generally unreceptive of his attempts at affection and communication. The only thing I dislike about the movie is just how unsympathetic it is. But it makes sense, because if you're cheating on somewhat you're not really thinking much about their feelings, or if you are, you block it out. Oh well, overall I'd say this is worth a view for people who want an honest look at marriage. It makes you realize just how much work a marriage takes. :) God Bless ~Amy
|  |
I don't mind if a film is slow-paced, so long as there is something of substance to grab me and hold my attention. The Secret Lives of Dentists is a forgettable trudge through middle-class family life and the mind of the dull and repressed dentist and dad, David Hurst, who is tormented by his unfaithful and distant wife and worn down by the demands his children make on him, even though he loves them all. Clumsy and awkward, the movie belabors the same points over and over again and slowly numbs your mind. Only one sequence of scenes stands out in memory - when the Hursts all come down with the flu and begin to vomit left and right. Great, I got the point that they were sick, but really, how much puke needs to fly in order to convey this fact?If you want to see a great film that stars Hope Davis, watch About Schmidt. It's also a slow-paced film that deals with ordinary, everday subject matter; however, unlike The Secret Lives of Dentists, About Schmidt is moving and thoughtful and will linger in your mind for days after you watch it.
|  |
|